Unraveling the Mystery of “Strange Metals”: Quantum Noise Experiments Shed Light on Unconventional Charge Flow

New research at Rice University provides direct evidence that strange metals exhibit unusual liquidlike charge flow, challenging the conventional understanding of quasiparticles.

In a groundbreaking study published in Science, researchers at Rice University have conducted quantum noise experiments that offer unprecedented insights into the behavior of “strange metals.” These quantum materials have long puzzled scientists with their unconventional properties, and the recent findings provide the first direct evidence that charge flows through strange metals in a liquidlike form that cannot be explained by the presence of quantized packets of charge known as quasiparticles. The discovery challenges our understanding of how electricity moves through materials and calls for a reevaluation of the fundamental concepts used in describing charge transport.

Unveiling the Secrets of Strange Metals:

The experiments focused on nanoscale wires made of a well-studied quantum critical material called ytterbium-rhodium-silicon (YbRh2Si2). This material exhibits a high degree of quantum entanglement, resulting in temperature-dependent behavior. When cooled below a critical temperature, YbRh2Si2 undergoes an instantaneous transition from non-magnetic to magnetic. At temperatures slightly above the critical threshold, it manifests as a “heavy fermion” metal, with charge-carrying quasiparticles that are significantly more massive than bare electrons.

The Elusive Nature of Quasiparticles:

Quasiparticles are theoretical constructs used by physicists to represent the collective behavior of countless interacting electrons in metals. However, prior theoretical studies have suggested that strange metal charge carriers may not conform to the quasiparticle model. To test this idea, the research team, led by Rice’s Doug Natelson and former student Liyang Chen, conducted shot noise measurements—a technique that quantifies the granularity of charge flow—in the YbRh2Si2 crystals.

Uncovering Unusual Charge Flow:

The shot noise measurements revealed a surprising result: the noise in strange metals was greatly suppressed compared to ordinary wires. This observation suggests that quasiparticles may not be well-defined entities or may not exist at all in strange metals. Instead, charge appears to move in more complex ways that defy conventional explanations. The researchers emphasize the need to develop a new vocabulary to describe this collective charge transport phenomenon accurately.

Technical Challenges and Empirical Evidence:

Performing shot noise experiments on the YbRh2Si2 crystals presented significant technical hurdles. The crystalline films had to be grown with exceptional precision, and the wires made from the crystal needed to be about 5,000 times narrower than a human hair. Despite these challenges, the team successfully obtained direct empirical evidence that supports the hypothesis of charge flow in strange metals occurring through unconventional means.

Implications and Future Directions:

The implications of this research extend beyond YbRh2Si2. The researchers speculate that similar unconventional charge flow behavior may be present in other compounds exhibiting strange metal behavior. The phenomenon of “strange metallicity” appears to be a universal characteristic across various physical systems, even those with vastly different underlying physics. The linear-in-temperature resistivity, a hallmark of strange metals, suggests a generic mechanism at play, independent of the microscopic building blocks of the materials.


The recent quantum noise experiments at Rice University have provided groundbreaking insights into the behavior of strange metals. The discovery of suppressed shot noise in these materials challenges the conventional understanding of quasiparticles and calls for a reevaluation of how charge moves collectively in quantum materials. As scientists strive to find the right vocabulary to describe this unconventional charge transport, further research is needed to explore the implications of these findings in other compounds exhibiting strange metal behavior. The quest to unravel the mysteries of strange metals continues, paving the way for new discoveries in quantum materials and their applications.






Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *